Just after my blog post I met the NZOSS President Don Christie during a event here in Wellington, and he told me I was in the wrong side of the fence on this one. But we agreed that we have to find a side and stick with it anyway...
Since then Standards New Zealand decided to cast NO to the OpenXML standard, but Standards New Zealand has created an advisory group to meet for five days in Geneva to discuss concerns raised during the voting. The participants in this group are Internet NZ, NZ Open Source Society (technical), NZ Open Source Society (strategist), IBM NZ, Microsoft NZ, Microsoft NZ partner, Archives New Zealand, State Services Commission and the NZ Computer Society.
Now I have received a copy of a document written by CompTIA's Michael Mudd, and I am reproducing the document here because it pretty much reflects my way of thinking on this matter.
The CompTIA is a global trade association representing the business interests of the information technology industry. For more than 25 years CompTIA has provided research, networking and partnering opportunities to its 20,000 plus members in 102 countries. The association is involved in developing standards and best practices, and influencing the political, economic and educational arenas that impact IT worldwide.
Future-proofing IT Policy – is it possible, or desirable?
By Michael Mudd
I imagine you’re enjoying this article on your Kenbak-2000 personal computer, or secretly wishing you were the richest man in the world, John Blankenbaker. This easily could have been the case if in 1971 the Kenbak-1, subsequently considered by the Computer History Museum as the world’s first ‘personal computer (PC),’ had been recognized as the sole standard for the future development of the PC.
Think; no 1977 Trinity (Apple II, TRS-80, and Commodore PET) or IBM 5150 in 1981, which arguably set the scene for the entire PC era, making household names of previously niche players such as Intel and Microsoft. Thankfully, while certain patents were awarded to the Kenbak-1, we can thank IT industry policy-makers of the time for seeing how much more innovation and invention was left in the PC industry. Even more importantly the market needed more time to reward the companies who were delivering systems that could best meet their needs. This ability to create an environment where innovation flourished, while intellectual property was still credited and protected means that today nearly two billion PCs have been sold, versus the 40 Kenbak-1 PCs that made it off the production line.
The ability to allow continuous market-driven innovation, rather than creating standards and policies based on an early view of what the world of tomorrow might look like is central to business success – it means that you’re not deciphering this article from Morse code, or driving to work in a Model-T Ford.
Why is Innovation Important - Open Innovation versus Closed Innovation
The advent of the Internet has fundamentally changed the way the businesses define business models and harness innovation. Henry Chesbrough in his book “Open Innovation, the New Imperative for Creating Profit from Technology” refers to the time before and after the Internet, as ‘Closed Innovation’ and ‘Open Innovation,’ respectively.
Before the wide adoption of the Internet, innovation used to be a closed process, undertaken with a silo-mentality. Business leaders used to think that to profit from research and development that, like John Blankenbaker, they had to be first to market. They would have to directly hire people to make discoveries, develop and market the discoveries themselves and then use tools such as patents to control this intellectual property so that competitors could not share in the spoils.
Chesbrough notes that today’s Internet-powered competitive business landscape makes closed innovation increasing hard to achieve. Incredibly fluid employee availability and mobility, the proliferation of small market-driven technology businesses (e.g. today small businesses accounted for over 99 per cent of all businesses), outsourcing, off shoring and the proliferation of new market-driven sources of innovation means that with great product choice and faster innovation cycles that customers increasingly want product interoperability, rather than a rigid, pre-defined single-standard.
Document Standards – Why Should Businesses Care?
There is an interoperability versus single-standard debate raging at the moment, which has a direct impact on business – should the Open Document Format (ODF) be the sole standard for business documents, or should Office Open XML (OOXML) also be allowed a choice for businesses and document users?
Data formats have been around as long as computing. They reflect the varying capabilities and functions of different computing systems and have evolved as those computing systems have evolved. Punch cards were once commonplace, but you wouldn’t think to use them today. In the decades since their use, a wide range of formats (TXT, PDF, HTML, and DOC, to name a few) have become popular because they meet specific user needs and tap into new computing capabilities.
Two years ago Microsoft submitted Office Open XML to Ecma International, an international association founded in 1961 and dedicated to the standardization of information, to go through the process to make it an open standard. A growing list of companies, including Microsoft, Apple, Novell, Xandros, Linspire, TurboLinux, Corel and Dataviz recognized the desire of users of their software to work with multiple formats and are giving those users the tools they need to do so. However, despite industry belief that customers would be happy to choose, there is a chance in March next year that some national body members of the ISO may not approve OOXML as a document standard. In a preliminary vote last September, 51 national bodes voted yes, but under the consensus system of the ISO this was insufficient.
We should expect the creation of new formats in the future as technology evolves (e.g. Uniform Office Format, or UOF, under development in China, also a group of former ODF supporters have broken away from the ODF standard and are now promoting another document format standard called CDF), and as has always been the case, users should be able to choose the formats that work best for them, especially if they are fundamentally different formats that meet different needs in the marketplace, as is the case here.
OOXML sceptics argue that OOXML contains Microsoft-specific legacy formats which can cause interoperability problems, and will serve only to strengthen Microsoft's domination in the office productivity software market. OOXML is already being used in the 2007 Microsoft Office system, making it easier for people to use the software suite that creates the vast majority of the world’s business document to create and share documents, regardless of the platform or application.
Customers who want to work with multiple formats can do so now and into the future through the use of tools called ‘connectors.’ However, the simple fact is that OOXML should be agreed as an interoperable standard along with ODF (and whatever other standards meet the criteria) to allow the market to choose which one they will use to achieve what they need with their business documents.
Standards and policy – when the market decides, we all win!
Suppose Charles H. Duell, Director of the U.S. Patent Office had shut it down following his 1899 proclamation that ‘everything that can be invented, has been invented.” When people take a narrow view of what is achievable through technology, innovation is the inevitable collateral damage – especially dangerous at a time when the governments of Asia are looking to ICT as a major value-add to economic outputs and creating jobs.
I recently attended a meeting in Malaysia where there was a clear statement from the Honourable Dato Dr. Jamaludin Jarjis, Malaysia’s Minister of Schience, Technology and Innovation, that the country should adopt an open innovation model and that this should be market driven. CompTIA supports industry standards and strongly believes that standards such as OOXML are good for any countries in the region that want to pursue Open Innovation approaches. I’m not necessarily saying that the market would choose to use OOXML, but the market needs the opportunity to decide, otherwise we could be building an environment that stifles, rather than encourages innovation.
If Mr. Duell had done that in 1899, I might still be wearing a fashionable Victorian knee length frock coat and a top hat.
Michael Mudd, Director of Public Policy, Asia-Pacific, CompTIA.
Mike Mudd is the Director of Public Policy for Asia Pacific and has responsibility for running CompTIA’s Public Policy initiatives for the region encompassing Japan to Australia and China and India. This region, home to half the worlds population is also amongst the most dynamic and challenging for the ICT industry in the 21st century.
I agree with its basis that a standard doesn't need to be a single unique entity, but it can be multiple agreed codes.
For full disclosure I must inform you that I found this document with the help of Microsoft New Zealand. Of course if the NZOSS or any other commenter wants to send me something similar I am happy to write about it too. Or just comment below.
So here is the invitation in its original form:
You are invited to apply to the worldwide Technium Challenge organised by International Business Wales (IBW - http://www.ibwales.com/) and Technium UK.
The Technium Challenge (http://www.technium.co.uk/) is a unique business planning competition that helps winners expand overseas. It is targeted to smart Kiwi SME technology companies looking to launch into UK, European and other international markets.
Entering the Technium Challenge will give you the opportunity to take your next step on the global stage. If you’re ready to accelerate your plans to set up a UK sales and marketing office or work with UK partners and distributors to deliver your offerings to more customers, begin with the Technium Challenge.
Winners will receive a host of benefits including:
- free UK office space for a year within a Technium Innovation centre and an intense international arrival support package;
- on-going guidance and support for developing an international business plan;
- the New Zealand finalist will be taken on a Learning Journey to Wales where they will be introduced to like-minded companies, advanced business networks and leading researchers in their field.
Application is simple. You are invited to submit an executive summary of your Company’s business plan to Rhodri Jones (IBW) – the closing date for entries is 5 p.m. Friday 28 March 2008.
Applicants who qualify will receive help in developing an international business plan, which will need to be submitted to the judging panel by Friday 4 April. You will then briefly present your business plan to New Zealand judges Rod Oram (leading Business Commentator) and Chris Jones (CEO, Mobilis Networks and Ernst & Young Entrepreneur of the Year) in April.
The New Zealand finalist will then make their way to Cardiff in May for their ‘Learning Journey to Wales’ and to compete against other country finalists in the final leg of the competition.
So, are you ready for the challenge?
The latest one is Air France and OnAir. According to Wi-Fi Networking News:
The service is limited to text messaging and mobile email for the first half of the six-month trial. In three months, voice service will be enabled, but according to interviews I’ve conducted over the last couple of years, the voice part could be summarily disabled during flights or for the remainder of the trial depending on reception.
Calls may be made only above 10,000 feet (3,000m). OnAir said they have arrangements with several cell carriers—the company’s service is like its own cell carrier in the air—including Orange, Bouyges Telecom, and SFR. The cost is “comparable” to international calling, and is estimated to be about US$2.50 per minute in previous reports and interviews.
I hope this doesn't work well. Really, who needs a twelve hour flight over the Pacific Ocean with 400 people on-board and some folks send and receiving SMS (beep, beep), phones playing noisy horrible ringtones and worse of all - people talking loudly about their big deal, the new house, or whatever is important for them - forgetting there are some people trying to sleep on that big flying tube...
If this comes true I hope airlines indicate in the booking something like "Mobile free flight" so people can choose which flight to take.
Entries are closing soon...
The group was created as an extension of the BarCamp Auckland 2007 and is designed to discuss social-media in New Zealand and how it relates to Advertising, Web, Marketing and most importantly communities.
An interesting mashup is Nigel Parker's suggestion for the the first live meeting: why not on board of an Air New Zealand plane? For this he created a "flight" in the Grab-a-plane promotion: join the "flight" and when it is full it will be in the draw so the entire group can win an airplane for a full day.
Ludwig Wendzich did a great job organising the event. The location was great, and the infrastructure provided was really good - including wireless Internet access, meeting rooms, support, coffee, lunch and a LCD with live Twitter updates.
Whoever wrote he was too young to pull this off was wrong.
I tell you that: if you didn't go to BarCamp Auckland 2007 because of this, then you missed a great deal of technical information and good networking. And the lunch.
I counted about 80 people around there, and attended five sessions throughout the day. Robert O'Callahan presented Mozilla 3.0 - didn't you know parts of the Mozilla development is made in Auckland, good old New Zealand? Now you know.
Mainly the new Firefox 3.0 seems to bring lots of graphics and typography updates, including video - but Robert wasn't able to tell us exactly what happened to the "offline application" framework that was presented to another audience earlier this year during the Kiwi Foo Camp.
Simon Young led a session on using social media for PR work - with some good comments on this. And Nigel Parker ran a session on new Microsoft technologies - hey it's not only Open Source there!
I had the opportunity to meet some Geekzoners during the event, as well as meet old and new friends. Also met a couple of Vodafone New Zealand folks and a Telecom New Zealand guy attending the event. Good to see them there!
By 5pm I was in a cab heading to the airport to fly back home - a long day, but worth it. Certainly coming back for the next one.
You can see pictures on Flickr tagged as BarCampAuckland.
You can join the Geekzone flight now - full planes go in the draw to win the flight to anywhere in New Zealand for a full day - for everyone in the plane. The flight plan is Wellington - Dunedin. so if you join the flight, be prepared to depart from Wellington.
You can also create your own flight to other destinations.
Before lunch (at the Wellington's famous Logan Brown) we had a brief review of Telecom's performance during 2007. Then we had a few bits of news (and I will quote from my notes):
- The Okta Touch is the fastest selling Windows Mobile device on Telecom ever - with about three times more sales than originally expected.
- The voicemail migration should be completed by January 2008 - a long project, which I remember being involved during early planning stages while working for Unisys New Zealand, until now provider of the Telecom VSP (voice platform).
- The Worldmode service will have some new handsets. If you don't know, "worldmode" are those handsets that can be used on the existing CDMA network and on overseas GSM/3G networks (and by the end of 2008 on the new Telecom network replacing the CDMA EVDO technology).
- Data roaming is coming for Worldmode so that you don't have to use CDMA only - and stuck in countries where there's no CDMA providers.
- The Okta Mondo should be announced next week, the second Worldmode handset from Telecom New Zealand.
- The LG Groove is coming next month - a media-oriented handset with special media keys (it reminds me of those MP3 players) and built-in FM transmitter.
- Telecom New Zealand is working on launching a Worldmode BlackBerry handset. Initially they are working on testing internally at Gen-i, but soon with external clients.
- They are working on a Samsung Blackjack Windows Mobile device codenamed Albero, also to be a Worldmode handset, due to release sometime near the end of Q1 2008.
- A free security software is coming for Yahoo!Xtra (Bubble) users.
- More broadband business plans are coming in addition to currently existing residential plans.
- Telecom New Zealand will move into the business services during 2008 including hosted applications.
In summary, as Greg McAlister said:
Embracing the new opportunities and looking forward to operating as a service provider in the new environment
It seems everyone there is quite happy with Telecom's new CEO, Paul Reynolds. Good luck in 2008...
The upper management wanted BlackBerry devices because they wanted whatever the guy sitting next to them in the airplane had.
The people working in the front wanted a device that could actually be used for something else than just e-mail.
My suggestion was Windows Mobile - mainly because it was the platform that could easily access their private network through a HTTPS VPN proxy they already had in place, and because it would be much easier to deploy e-mail synchronisation with their Exchange Servers through SSL, without having to invest in additional hardware for a BES server.
One year later I still consider this solution the best option. Take in consideration that now Microsoft is coming out with tools that allow Windows Mobile devices to join a domain and IT administrators have the ability to manage those mobile devices as they would manage any other computer on their network.
The recently announced Microsoft System Center Mobile Device Manager 2008 is looking like a great tool for IT administrators to keep an eye on mobile devices inside the organisation.
Now I read this interesting post about database synchronisation betwen mobile devices and server. The platform runs on SQL Server and SQL Server Compact 3.1 using Merger Replication technologies:
I decided to double the number of concurrent Subscribers to 600. Keep in mind that each Subscriber is equivalant to a Windows Mobile device. I used 6 servers running 100 Subscribers each to create client load, 3 load-balanced IIS servers, and a separate SQL Server Distributor and Publisher. With 600 concurrent Subscribers contending for resources, I managed to perform 22,401 syncs per hour which is slightly fewer syncs than I saw when running only 300 Subscribers back in Vegas. The important story here is that I almost doubled the number of rows I changed and replicated per hour:
- Rows changed: 13,440,600 per hour | 322,574,400 per day
- Data replicated: 1.45 GB per hour | 34.8 GB per day
Database is a very cool technology and having the ability to "mobilise" data is one of the most important parts of mobility in my view.
This will be the fourth year NZTE attends the event with some local technology companies. NZTE is the New Zealand government's national economic development agency.
This year’s theme will focus on enhanced communication between humans and computers. Visitors to the stand will be able to see and work with interactive technologies, see a robot in operation, as well as experience demonstrations of telematic technologies and banking applications.
This is a list with companies and technologies participating this year, from the press release:
Human-Computer Interaction: Technology for all the senses
NextWindow is a designer and developer of touch screen products, designed for a variety of applications, including after-market touch sensitive overlays to Interactive WhiteBoard touch and annotation. NextWindow will be showing multi-touch capability, and object size recognition, both new functionalities in the large touch screen market.
Massive Software (www.massivesoftware.com)
Massive Software provides a premier 3D animation system for generating crowd-related visual effects for film and television. The animation and simulation software is used by filmmakers, engineers, architects and robot developers. The company will host Hanson Robotics’ robot Zeno at the show which uses a Massive Software brain to interact with its environment.
Simtrix Ltd (www.simtrix.co.nz)
Simtrix is a leader in research, design, and marketing of breakthrough technologies within the field of Human-Computer Interaction (HCI). Simtrix has developed the Swiftpoint device - a radically different computer mouse (or pointing device) that is operated between the index finger and thumb eliminating the need for additional desktop space.
Aranz Scanning Ltd (www.aranz.com)
Aranz develops and supplies handheld 3D laser surface scanning systems and software for acquiring, processing and quantitative analysis of 3D surface data. Examples of integration projects include a mask making system for creating immobilisation masks for radiotherapy and facilitating a faster and less invasive way to create prosthetics and orthotics than the more traditional casting methods.
Banking: Secure and easy to use solutions for the banking industry
Fronde Anywhere (www.frondeanywhere.com)
Fronde Anywhere offers mobile banking, payment and multi-factor authentication solutions for retail banks and other players in the financial services industry. Its portfolio of user-friendly solutions enables customers to make payments and bank transactions via their mobile device from any location.
Vcomms offers a new generation of Financial Transaction Network solutions. The company delivers a range of secure wireless connectivity solutions that enable Cash Machine (ATM), Kiosk and Electronic Point Of Sale (EPOS) terminals to connect to transaction processors and banks over Internet Protocol (IP) networks. Vcomms provides solutions to customers in the banking, telecommunications, independent ATM deployer and OEM sectors.
Business Software: Easing the way we work at a mouse-click
Author-it Software Corporation (www.author-it.com)
Author-it is the complete solution for the creation, management and publication of content across the whole enterprise. From software user assistance and training, to sales proposals, to product manuals, to marketing collateral, to policies and procedures.
Centruflow Ltd (www.centruflow.com)
Centruflow’s world-leading suite of products enables users to visually inspect and understand the data that is important to their business. Centruflow draws pictures that can be easily understood and trusted. It visually connects people to knowledge, linking actions to consequences.
Pivot Ltd (www.pivot.net.nz)
Pivot offers HR software for remuneration management leading to improved organisational efficiency and employee engagement. Its flagship product – Remuneration Decision Assistant (R.D.A.) manages the critical workflow process of pay reviews through leading edge web-based technology eliminating the more typical spreadsheet or manual processes.
Starsoft Limited (www.starsoft.co.nz)
Starsoft’s EziDoesIT software is an add-in for Microsoft Outlook 2003 and 2007 which allows users to visually prioritise emails into tasks and then schedule these tasks automatically into the Outlook Calendar according to their priority. The team edition allows managers to maximise work resources for meeting project and task scheduling goals.
Telematics: Technology that shows you the way
Daestra NZ Ltd (www.daestra.com)
Daestra NZ provides advanced telematic B2B software solutions that will change the way business is done. Its flagship consumer product TracPlus™ showcases Daestra’s technology's ability to seamlessly integrate global tracking across land, sea and air markets in a single solution, regardless of what sensor technology is used.
International Telematics (www.itelematic.com)
International Telematics is a leader in the design and development of telematic hardware and software solutions. This includes GPS tracking, remote vehicle diagnostics (OBDII & CAN), temperature monitoring, managed telematic platforms, accident metrics and driver behaviour.
Imarda is a global company specialising in Telematics hardware products and software solutions for fleet management. Uniquely, Imarda provides complete Telematics solution from end-to-end ensuring the integration of technical compatibility between hardware and software is totally seamless.
Immigration and Employment Service: Living and Working in New Zealand
Hudson Recruitment and Immigration NZ (www.immigration.govt.nz, www.hudson.com)
Hudson, a market leader in IT recruitment, and the government authority Immigration New Zealand assist ICT professionals and people from different industries to start a career in New Zealand. Hudson and Immigration NZ are especially looking to recruit IT experts at CeBIT.
New Zealand’s IT industry pavilion at CeBIT
The pavilion situated in Hall 14 Stand G38 is part of an initiative run by New Zealand Trade and Enterprise (NZTE). NZTE supports New Zealand’s IT and telecommunications industry in Europe and aims to highlight the technology expertise within New Zealand. NZTE serves as a point of contact for international importers, agents, distributors, traders and investors with innovative companies from New Zealand. There are 39 NZTE branches, including offices in London, UK and Hamburg, Germany.
There is even a NZTE at CeBIT blog where you can get up-to-date information.